| Project | Claim issue | Year |
| Bar–Boljare Highway of Smokovac–Uvac–Mateseo
(21 bridges, 16 tunnels and 40 km of roads) Montenegor
800 000 000,00 eur FIDIC Red book 1999
|
– Failure in approving couplers
– Engineer’s Instructed Reinforcement Measures for Safety Proving
– Engineer’s Instruction to Employ Intl Consultant for Design Review
|
2016 |
| Construction of Bulancak Water Supply Project Trukey
10 000 000,00 eur FIDIC Red book 1999 |
– Error/defect in design
– Inadequate Engineer’s instruction
|
2016 |
| Waste Water and Treatment Plant, Component 2
BIh
12 000 000,00 eur Yellow FIIDIC book 1999
|
– Delay payment of IPC’s by the Employer
– Delay in finalization of Waste Water and Storm Water Collection Networks LOT 1–3– Component 1 as precondition for completion of Works of Component 2 – non–regulated Stabilization of slope along the access road – absence of medium voltage equipment and power supply on the plant
|
2016 |
| Construction of 400 kV OHL Lastva–Pljevlja (section Cevo–Pljevlja) and associated 110 kV OHL diversions
Montenegro
30 000 000,00 eur Yellow FIIDIC book 1999
|
– Non–adequate Engineer’s instruction in respect of scope of application of DC towers scope of application of DC towers
– non–resolved property rights – inadequate variations |
2016 |
| Krnovo Wind Power Plant
Montenegro
10 000 000,00 eur FIDIC Red book 1999
|
– non–availability of site possession
– stoppages of works
|
2016 |
| Water Supply and Sanitation Adriatic Coast III–Herceg Novi
18 000 000,00 eur RED FIDIC book 1999 |
– Culvert in Savina
– Exisiting Water Supply in Denovici – Changes in Electrical connections for Pumping Stations – Extraordinary Rainfall –PS Denovici 10kV cable – Changed Ground conditions in Kumbor – Stoppage due to Termination of Contract – New EE conditions – Change in EE Conditions for PS Meljine Old |
2016 |
| Urgent Maintenance and Remedy of Damages on the State Road IIA 170 Rogacica–BajinaBasta
5 000 000,00 eur
FIDIC Yellow book 1999 |
– delay in desing technical control
– floods – “zero change” deviations |
2016 |
| Belgrade Waterfront
20 000 000,00 eur FIDIC red book 1999
|
– lack of access to and possession of site
– deviation in traffic regime – lack of permits – unexploded ordnances – defective design documents – delay in design technical control – change in design – non–regulated modification of works
|
2015 |
| Zemun–Borca Bridge with the Accompanying Roads
Intersection–crossroad of North Tangent road with Zage Malivuk Street on LOT8 – North Tangent Road from Kovilovo interchange to and including Railway bridge
40 000 000,00 eur |
– the relocation of high voltage cable
–adverse weather conditions – change of scope of works – accelerations – delay in land acquisition |
2015 |
| Reconstruction of street Vojvode Stepe in Belgrade
20 000 000,00 eur FIDIC red book 1999
|
– deviation in traffic management plan
– unforeseeable site conditions |
2015 |
| Shoe Plant in Vranje
10 000 000,00 eur FIDIC red book 1999
|
– exceptionally adverse climatic conditions
– change in design |
2014 |
| GRDELICA (GORNJE POLJE)–CARICINA DOLINA
LOT 3:TUNNEL PREDEJANE and CARICINA DOLINA–VLADICIN HAN, LOT 4: TUNNEL MANAJLE
25 000 000,00 eur
MDBH 2005 FIDIC
|
– Lack of access to and possession of the Site
– Delay in provision of the Construction Permit
– delay due to inadequate deposit area
– Delay due to unforeseeable physical site conditions
– discrepancies in geological conditions
– delay in progress of works of tunnel Predejane, South portal, caused by discrepancies in actual geological conditions and those foreseen in Design
– delay in approval tunnel’s formwork design
|
2013–2016 |
| Construction of Highway E75, Section: Grdelica (Gornje Polje)–Caričina Dolina LOT 1 : Road and Bridges from Grdelica to Tunnel Predejane, Contract No CORRX.E75.EIB.PACK1–LOT1.ICB
30 000 000,00 eur
MDBH 2005 FIDIC
|
– interference of. Telenor Targo 2.
– Design Deviations (3. –lack of Building Permit – non availability of Possession and Access to the Site – Relocation of 35 KV cable – floods – problems with slope stability |
2013–2016 |
| . Construction of Highway E80, Corridor X branch, Xc, Niš–Sofia, Section: Nis (Prosek)––Dimitrovgrad (Border Crossing with Bulgaria) Parallel–non–commercial road, Bela Palanka–– Pirot (West) (CORRX.E80.EBRD.B.lCB),
Construction of Highway E80 Section: Pirot (East) – Dimitrovgrad (remaining works) (CORRX.E80.EBRD.A2–RW.lCB),
Construction of Highway E80, Corridor X, branch Xc, Nis–Sofia, Nis (Prosek) – Dimitrovgrad /Border Crossing with Bulgaria), Section Dimitrovgrad bypass– Border Crossing (remaining works);ICB CORPX.E80.WB.PACK1–RW.JCBin
Construction of Highway E75, Section: Grdelica (Gornje Polje) – Caricina Dolina, LOT 2: Road and bridges from Tunnel Predejane to Caricina Dolina Contract ref CORRX.E75.EIB.PACK1.–LOT2.ICB
100 000 000,00 eur
MDBH 2005 FIDIC
|
Lack of access to and possession of the Site
Delay in provision of the Construction Permit
Delay in provision of parts of the certified Main Design
Adverse weather Conditions Delay in issuing requested instructions with regard to errors or defects in the Main Design
Delay due to unforeseeable physical site conditions |
2013–2016 |
| Fiat Automobili Srbija (FAS)
Kragujevac Plant Refurbishment Tenders 26a building 16
5 000 000,00
FIDIC Red book 1999 |
– delay in issuance commencement date
– unjustified suspension – change in design – omission of part of works
|
2011 |
| CONSTRUCTION OF ZEZELJ BRIDGE ACROSS THE DANUBE RIVER IN NOVI SAD
60 000 000,00 eur Yellow book FIDIC 1999 |
–contingency
– reduce rate of progress (lack of timely payments, lack of sufficient and adequate proof of Sub–Clause 2.4 “Employer’s Financial Arrangements”) – food (increased levels of river Danube) – unforeseeable site conditions ( wall around caisson) (remaining parts of original Pier 3) – errors in Employer’s requirements DAB– payment of contingencies – partial rejection of Contractor’s claim in pre–construction period:
(Delayed Final Design completion due to additional design works and lack of appropriate Design review as foreseen by the Contract and allowed by relevant legislation, and Delayed Application for and issuance of the Building Permit (under Employer’s responsibility).
Individually these events are:
– Delayed Terms of Reference for Final Design – Technical Control for preparatory works – Delayed Access to the Site – Inappropriate Design review procedure – Additional design works – Delayed report of Technical Control – Changes between Preliminary (provided in Tender) and Final Design – Delayed commencement of construction works (Building Permit)
|
2010–2016 |
| E 80 highway
Pirot –Dimitrovgrad– Baypass Dimitrovgrad Corridor x MDBH 2005 FIDIC 60 000 000,00 eur |
– Delayed Submission of the Approved Final Design
– Lack of Access to and Possession of the Site – Lack of Connection for the relocated 35 kV transmission headline – Lack of Access to and Possession of the Site at Bridge no4. – Defect in Drainage Design and Lack of Instruction at Bridge no 5. – Design Defect of Sewerage Pipe at Bridge no6 – Design Defect of Optical Cable at Bridge no6. – Additional Works of STA–PV (Railway) Cable at Bridge no6. – Blasting Obstructions – Changed Blasting Technology – Unforeseeable – Landslide Occurred at Gradina Cutting Area – Custom Problem of Beam’s Pre–stress Cable – Unforeseeable Subsoil Condition at Pier no. 10 and 11 on the RHS and at 11 on the LHS .. – Changed Design Solutions of Bridge no6 due to the New Requirements of the Public Enterprises„Serbian Railways“ and „Roads of Serbia – Construction of Protective Structure above Railway Contact Network – Construction of Retaining Structures beside Foundations for Piers S9 RHS and S10 LHS Contractor’s entitlement under the Contract provisions – Delayed Submission of the Approved Final Design – Lack of Access to and Possession of the Site – Lack of Connection for the relocated 35 kV transmission headline – Lack of Access to and Possession of the Site at Bridge no4. – Defect in Drainage Design and Lack of Instruction at Bridge no 5 – Design Defect of Sewerage Pipe at Bridge no6 – Design Defect of Optical Cable at Bridge no6
|
2010–2013 |
| Pavement Rehabilitation – Upgrading of Main Road M–7, section:
Kać – Žabalj, from km 52+422 to km 64+656, Contract ID: WBC/RRC–M7/2009–02” 18 000 000,00 eur
EIB conditions (PRAG)
|
– change in price elements which lead to increase of price more than 102%) | 2012 |
| Beska bridge over Danube and rehabilitation of existing bridge
100 000 000,00 eur
Yellow and Red FIDIC book 1999 |
– problems in obtaining construction permit
– Delay in issuing the Act of Urbanism, Report of the Revision Commission on Preliminary Design, Construction Approval application and Terms of Reference for Final Design – problem with Terms of references – problems with Site Data – Employer’s delay in providing necessary design input data for the design and construction of the new bridge (claim 9 (increased foundations left bank), 14 (box shape foundations), 15 (lack of as built drawings), 16 (additional stabilization right bank), 19 (new seismic data), 21 (use of Eurocode 8), 23 (hydro–technical data), 29 (lack of scour protection) and 31 (additional investigations right bank) – floods – Discovery of unexpected objects in the river bed delaying the excavation works in the river bed – Non availability of the third lane of the existing bridge for the construction of the new bridge – Delay caused by the construction of longer piles on the Left Bank – landslide stability of the Right Bank – Box shape foundations construction at piers 42 and 43 |
2009–2012 |
| Office and residential buildings
90 000m2 Belgrade 50 000,00 eur Old Red Fidic Book 1987 (Red book IV) |
– design problems –Alternative foundation design
– lack of Electro–energy approval – unforeseeable site conditions Underground installation on site – Unprecedented high water table level and dewatering – unexploded ordnances |
2009 |